And I am going to voice them.
Redundant spoiler warning: This blog post contains spoilers about Doctor Who and Buffy and a redundant spoiler warning about this blog post containing spoilers about Doctor Who and Buffy.
I watched the first episode of the second half of the sixth season of Doctor Who tonight with the Girl. Actually, let’s just start here.
Complaint #1. Why is it necessary to have a mid-season break? WHY? Did we need a reprieve? Was it getting too much for us? I think I read Steven Moffat saying something about this a while ago, actually, but I can’t remember what it was, but I bet it was something along the lines of “we wanted to build up the tension for the fans in a big way so they could really experience the wonder of Doctor Who.” I am going to get to your issues with ‘suspense’ in a minute, Steven Moffat. Don’t think you’re immune.
Alright, so, me and the Girl were watching the first episode of the second half of the sixth season of Doctor Who, Let’s Kill Hitler. For those of you who have not watched Doctor Who: watch it. Okay, see, I don’t dislike Doctor Who. Not in a general sort of way. Really. Watch it, starting from the first season of the revived series, and it will be fantastic and you will laugh and cry and ride an emotional rollercoaster of unicorns and dreams. So: I love Doctor Who. I stumbled upon the first season of the revived series when it aired here in Australia for the first time, not really knowing what it was, and was permanently hooked. It was more or less my first fanboyness. I got into the Harry Potter fandom a bit later, but Doctor Who was first. I’ve watched every season since then, as they aired.
Season one was fun. Season two was beautiful. Season three was clever. Season four was epic. Season five was disorienting. Season six is actively losing my interest — and it’s not just me; friends of mine are giving up on Doctor Who left, right, and centre. And I am going to rant about why.
I’m going to start specifically with this episode, because it’s repeated a lot of the errors the show’s made recently.
Complaint #2. Steven Moffat. I respect you as screenwriter and a showmaker. You are a genius of television writing. You wrote my favourite episodes in Doctor Who, three seasons, three times in a row. Blink was genius. Buffy The Vampire Slayer is my favourite TV show, but Blink knocked a lot of Buffy episodes off the ladder as it skyrocketed up there in the little personal rankings that live in my head. (The best episodes get cute little tiaras.) You (co-?) wrote Sherlock! You wrote Coupling! God, I love Coupling. So. We know you’re really good. What are you doing to Doctor Who? Let’s take tonight’s episode as an example. It starts in a cornfield. Good! I like corn. There’s Amy and Rory, in a car, in a cornfield, this is great! There’s dialogue! You can’t hear the dialogue over the music, but that’s for the next complaint. I wonder, fleetingly, what Amy and Rory are doing in a car in a cornfield but everything is going so fast that there is no point thinking about anything ohmygoodness. They find the TARDIS in a cornfield. The cornfield spells ‘Doctor’! Oh, brilliant, you two, brilliant! Okay, tearful reunion, the Doctor tells Amy he hasn’t found her daughter, some psycho girl appears, waves a gun around, cut to the title sequence.
It is at this point, as the theme swells around me, that I wonder why Amy isn’t, I don’t know, sodding bloody traumatised. Let’s think back to the previous episode. To cut a long story short, Amy and Rory had a child who is a Time Lord except because time travel Amy is still pregnant except because she’s a fake Amy she isn’t pregnant so the real Amy has been kidnapped and gives birth to her child and the Doctor and Rory bring together old friends and go rescue them and it’s tearful and bittersweet because everyone dies but they rescue the child but then NO the child is also a fake and dissolves and OH GOD but then River says no wait I’m your daughter it’s ALL OKAY and the Doctor vanishes in the TARDIS and Amy and Rory are shocked.
Well that wasn’t cutting a long story short, you say, but believe me it is.
So these are the things that have happened to Amy:
- She’s had a baby while kidnapped.
- She’s had the baby taken away from her.
- She’s been reunited with the baby only to find out it’s not real.
- She’s been reunited with the baby only to find out it’s sexy River Song and also no longer a baby.
So what does she do, after inexplicably getting home from a space station in the future (I assume) without the TARDIS because the Doctor ran away in it? She drives around in a cornfield and has adventures! Let’s kill Hitler! If I were a real person, I’d be a broken shell of a human being!
I’m not saying that Karen Gillan is a bad actress. She’s good! She’s preppy and responsive and funny and even stirs emotions in me which are not always related to her legs. I’m saying that her screenwriters, and by that I mean Steven Moffat, appear not to be able to articulate real human emotions in their characters. They substitute emotions with dramatic tension, and in a show where practically all the screen time is invested in the characters, that fine, isn’t it?
Complaint #3. I promised to mention the music. Seriously. Is this the same for everyone, or is it just Australia, or is it just our TV set? I think it was worse last season, but still — you know when there’s a dramatic moment brewing because that’s the part of the episode you have to read up on, later, on Wikipedia.
Complaint #4. I mentioned this above anyway, in passing, but now I’m going to mention it properly. Continuity. You might say ‘oh, but Doctor Who is a show without a fixed timeline, so continuity is hardly important!’ Well, you’re wrong. Doctor Who is a show without a fixed timeline, so continuity lets us understand it. There’s a constant slew of these problems, and they’re getting worse. It’s like Steven Moffat is at a desk somewhere, going ‘oh, oh my goodness, oh, and then this happens to them, I’m a genius!!’ which, granted, he may be, but if he’s a genius, it would be absolutely marvelous if he tried even the slightest bit to write the show so bits of it interconnected with other bits of in ways that make sense to us in our regular cause-and-effect-based timelines.
Complaint #5. What’s with the fad of putting new things into the show, building them up for twenty minutes, and then making a big reveal? It’s a) no fun and b) doesn’t work. Take Mels in this episode. She was inserted into the episode, out of the blue, because it’s more fun that way for those of us with eighteen brains, so that she’d be revealed as River fifteen minutes later. She was good enough friends with Amy for Amy to name her child after her. Amy has never mentioned her. Did Moffat think, ‘ooh, I need something dramatic to fill up the first fifteen minutes of this episode, I’ll just chuck this person retroactively into the timeline so that the audience can pathetically attempt to invest even the slightest bit of interest, not to say feeling, for her, considering that apparently she’s been hanging around Amy and Rory for the last decade, purely so I can use the Regeneration Budget.’ I’ve got an idea, Steven. Spend those fifteen minutes developing Amy’s character as a mother who’s lost all sense of stability in the universe before she’s even properly attained it; spend them explaining how they got back to Earth! And if you, random reader, reply that this way is more fun because action and fast cars and fun dialogue, then there’s nothing I can say to contradict you, but just remember that in the finale of the second season more emotion was conveyed in zero words because two characters pressed their faces against a wall than in the words, paraphrased, ‘I haven’t found your baby yet, but eh’.
Complaint #6. OH MY GOD STOP KILLING EVERYONE. You are not Joss Whedon. Note, by the way, that Joss Whedon used his awesome, soul-breaking powers of killing cast members about five times: Tara, Anya, Joyce, Buffy twice. Moreover, unlike Doctor Who characters, when Joss Whedon kills people, they stay dead (apart from Buffy, of course). Rory Williams has so far died approximately seventy billion times. The Doctor’s died twice. Amy died, I’m pretty sure. People keep turning into goops of Flesh. I think that Steven Moffat is turning into JK ‘There Was A Battle But You Missed Most Of It But Now All These People Are Dead Oh And Hedwig Too’ Rowling. I’ve practically given up investing myself emotionally into characters because there’s no point.
Complaint #7. The Weeping Angels and The Infinite Lameness. This is about the previous season, but I’m terrified that it’s going to happen again with The Silence. The story goes like this: in season 3 of Doctor Who, Steven Moffat wrote the best, funniest, most marvellous, most clever, sweetest Doctor Who episode, called Blink. There was an enemy in the episode who had the following qualities:
- With a touch, they’d send you back in time, but just far enough that by the time you got to the present, you’d be old and dying.
- They looked like angel statues (terrifying angel statues), and if you looked at them, they couldn’t move — if you blinked, for even a second, they’d attack.
That was it. It was amazing. But then Steven Moffat decided to make them a main enemy, and, because, presumably, the original incarnation of the Angels just wasn’t good enough, they gained the following qualities:
- They moved when the characters weren’t watching but we were, which made them look sort of like really confused stone interpretive dancers.
- They could speak.
- They were a bit funny.
And suddenly, the most terrifying Doctor Who enemy of all time was… kinda lame. Steven Moffat is brilliant, but doesn’t know when to stop. In other words, he ruins his own good ideas.
Complaint #8. The little things that ruin the big picture. How was River not poisoned by the poison on her lips? Maybe it was iocane powder, says the Girl, and she built up a resistance to it, because she comes from Australia, which is, as everyone knows, full of criminals. If the Tesselecta is out hunting for genocidal maniacs, wouldn’t they be interested in Doctor ‘I Destroyed Two Races’ Who? Is it because he dies at a fixed point in time that they can’t capture him? They weren’t planning on killing River, so why would they kill the Doctor — they’d just torture him. Why does nobody notice shouting, gunshots, a regeneration explosion and a TARDIS crash-landing in Hitler’s office? Oh, right, it’s all in the name of that elusive beast, dramatic tension. Well let me tell you, Steven Moffat. I wasn’t tense. And it was because I was losing my ability to suspend disbelief, which Doctor Who had done so well, so well in the past. And tiny continuinty errors isn’t your fault — Doctor Who isn’t so much full of them, as made out of them. But I have only started noticing them when the show has lost me to the extent that I start looking for things to pick on.
Don’t you see what you’re doing? Doctor Who is supposed to be fun because it’s magnificent, clever, witty, thought-provoking, trope-abusing and grandiose. Now all that’s left is fun, empty fun, propped up on dramatic tension that doesn’t go anywhere and supports no meaningful conclusions, and then you attempt to bring the fun and the dramatic tension to a satisfying finale but instead you leave your audience confused, unhappy, and lost.
And that is not how Doctor Who should be.